AI Tutor vs Maths Genie: Which Helps KS3 More?

Maths Genie is an excellent free resource for worksheets and worked examples; an AI tutor is better when your child needs feedback on their thinking, not just the right answer. Most KS3 families benefit from using both — Maths Genie to find the right practice material, an AI tutor to work through it interactively.

What is Maths Genie and what does it offer?

Maths Genie is a free UK maths revision website built specifically for GCSE and A-level students, with substantial coverage of KS3 topics. It provides downloadable PDF worksheets, worked-example videos, and past-paper questions organised by topic — from basic number and fractions through to algebra, geometry, and statistics.

The site is widely recommended by UK maths teachers and is genuinely good. Its key strengths are breadth (it covers virtually every topic a KS3 student will encounter), quality of worked examples, and the price: zero. There is no account to create, no subscription, and no upsell.

What Maths Genie does well:

Comprehensive topic-by-topic worksheets aligned to UK maths specifications

Clear, step-by-step worked examples for each topic

Free past-paper questions organised by grade difficulty

No sign-up or subscription required

Works on any device, including printing for offline use

What Maths Genie does not do:

Respond to your child's answers with targeted feedback

Identify which step of a problem your child is misunderstanding

Adapt what it shows next based on what the student has demonstrated

Provide the back-and-forth dialogue that builds deeper understanding

What does an AI tutor add?

An AI tutor is interactive where Maths Genie is static. When a KS3 student attempts a Maths Genie worksheet question and gets it wrong, the worksheet cannot tell them why they went wrong. An AI tutor can.

A Socratic AI tutor asks the student to explain their reasoning step by step. If a student made an error rearranging an equation, the AI can identify whether the mistake was with negative signs, order of operations, or a conceptual misunderstanding about inverse operations — and then address exactly that misconception, rather than simply showing the correct method again.

This matters because the Education Endowment Foundation's evidence on digital technology consistently shows that tools producing active retrieval and targeted feedback outperform tools that provide content for students to consume passively. A worksheet is passive; a guided conversation that requires the student to think, explain, and correct themselves is active.

What an AI tutor adds over Maths Genie:

Real-time feedback on why an answer is wrong, not just that it is wrong

Adaptive questioning that adjusts difficulty based on responses

Socratic dialogue that builds understanding rather than pattern-matching

Coverage across all KS3 subjects, not just maths

Safeguarding design appropriate for under-14s

Where an AI tutor is weaker than Maths Genie:

Maths Genie's worksheets are printable and work offline

Maths Genie has a larger bank of past-paper questions on demand

Maths Genie costs nothing; a quality AI tutor typically costs £10–£20 per month

Side-by-side comparison

Criterion | Maths Genie | AI tutor (e.g. aitutors.me)
Cost | Free | Typically £10–£20/month
How it teaches | Worksheets + video explanations | Interactive Socratic dialogue
Feedback on wrong answers | None — shows the solution | Asks why, addresses the misconception
Adapts to the student | No — same content for everyone | Yes — adjusts difficulty and focus
UK KS3/GCSE maths coverage | Comprehensive | Varies by provider; good products cover all core topics
Other subjects | Maths only | Multi-subject AI tutors cover English, science, humanities
Best for | Finding the right practice questions | Understanding why errors happen and fixing them
Offline use | Yes (printable PDFs) | No — requires internet connection

The honest case for Maths Genie as a first port of call

Maths Genie is hard to beat as a free, zero-friction revision resource. If your child's school sets maths homework and they need extra practice questions on, say, solving simultaneous equations, Maths Genie will surface exactly the right worksheet in under a minute. That is genuinely useful, and no AI tutor replaces it.

The site's worked examples are also well-presented and mathematically accurate — they follow the same step-by-step approach a maths teacher would use, which helps students who learn best by reading through a method before trying it themselves.

Where the AI tutor wins

The limitation of Maths Genie becomes apparent when a student has attempted the practice and still cannot see where they go wrong. They read the worked example, understand it in the moment, attempt the next question, and make the same mistake again. This is the central problem with passive learning: recognition is not the same as retrieval. The student recognises the correct method when they see it, but cannot reproduce it independently.

A Socratic AI tutor breaks this cycle. Instead of showing the method again, it asks the student to walk through their thinking aloud. "You wrote 3x = 12, then x = 9 — can you show me the step between those two?" The student has to engage with exactly where their reasoning broke down.

A practical approach for KS3 families

The two tools are more complementary than competitive. A sensible approach:

Use Maths Genie to find the right topic and practice questions.

Attempt the questions independently, without looking at the worked examples.

Where a student is stuck or getting questions wrong after two or three attempts, bring an AI tutor into the session to work through the misconception interactively.

Return to Maths Genie for further practice once the underlying issue is resolved.

This pattern — find the material with Maths Genie, understand it with an AI tutor — uses the strengths of each tool without paying for more than you need.

Frequently asked questions

Is Maths Genie good for Year 7 and Year 8 students?

Yes. Although Maths Genie's most extensive content is aimed at GCSE (Years 10–11), its foundational topics — fractions, percentages, algebra, geometry — are directly relevant to KS3 (Years 7–9). Most Year 7 and 8 students doing extra maths practice will find the "foundation" and "grade 1–3" questions appropriate. It works well as a source of extra practice questions at the right level.

Can an AI tutor replace a maths teacher or human tutor?

No product honestly makes this claim. A human teacher or tutor brings professional judgement, real-time observation of body language, and a relationship that supports motivation in ways AI cannot replicate. An AI tutor is better understood as an always-available practice partner — available at 9pm before a test, at a fraction of the cost of a human session, and patient enough to try the same concept five different ways. It supplements, rather than replaces, teaching.

What is the best free maths revision resource for KS3?

Among free resources, Maths Genie and BBC Bitesize are consistently recommended by UK maths teachers. Maths Genie is stronger on worked examples and practice questions; BBC Bitesize is stronger on accessible introductions to topics and includes science, English, and other subjects. Khan Academy is another free option with strong video explanations for KS3 maths. The best choice depends on whether your child needs to discover a topic, practise it, or understand where they are going wrong.

How much does an AI tutor for KS3 maths typically cost?

In 2026, purpose-built AI tutoring for KS3 typically costs £10–£20 per month. This compares with human tutors at £30–£60 per hour. At £14 per month, a tool like aitutors.me provides unlimited Socratic tutoring sessions — more total practice time than most families could afford with a human tutor, available whenever the student wants it.

See how aitutors.me's Socratic tutors compare for yourself at aitutors.me.